
By the time Prom Night IV: Deliver Us from Evil arrived in the early ’90s, the Prom Night franchise had already reinvented itself more than once. But this time, it may have finally gone too far. There’s no returning killer. Almost no connection to the previous movies. And somehow, a movie called Prom Night IV doesn’t even take place at a prom.
The fourth Prom Night movie abandoned nearly everything that connected the series, replacing the familiar teen slasher formula with a bizarre story about a murderous priest, childhood trauma, religious fanaticism, and a whole lot of questionable filmmaking decisions. And believe it or not, there was supposed to be a Prom Night V. It was actually made before being stripped of the Prom Night name altogether. Then there’s the dangerously low budget stunt that nearly burned a man for real.
So what happened behind the scenes? Why did Prom Night keep reinventing itself until there was barely anything left to recognize? And did Deliver Us from Evil finally become one reinvention too many?
What Is Prom Night IV: Deliver Us from Evil About?
For the uninitiated, it’s only right to begin with a plot refresher. Careful, though. You may lose a few brain cells trying to compute this dull, nonsensical tripe. The movie opens at a 1957 prom at Hamilton High School, the same setting as the previous three films and essentially the only connection between the franchise installments.
A couple of horny students, Brad and Lisa, ditch the dance to do the dirty deed in the backseat of Brad’s car. Before they can get very far, however, a manically furious priest emerges from the darkness and slashes Lisa’s throat with a metal crucifix. The priest is Father Jonas, a deeply disturbed religious fanatic who believes he must punish promiscuous teenagers. He promptly kills Brad and sets his car ablaze.
Back at the local church, Jonas explains that he was sexually abused as a child by priests at St. Basil Seminary. His traumatic past has supposedly turned him into a homicidal fanatic obsessed with murdering teenagers he considers sinful.
Jonas soon experiences an apparent religious stigmata, bleeding from his palms in front of the other priests while moaning in ecstasy. Father Jaeger declares him an abomination and sends him to St. George, where he is imprisoned in the church’s bowels for 33 years, strapped to a bed and fed drugs.
Then the movie jumps to 1991. Somehow, Jonas hasn’t aged a day. Inside St. George, Father Collins is assigned to monitor him. Collins is played by Brock Simpson, who appeared in all four Prom Night movies as a different character each time. In the original, he played 11-year-old Nick McBride. In Hello Mary Lou: Prom Night II, he played Josh, and in Prom Night III: The Last Kiss, he played police officer Larry.
Composer Paul Zaza also worked on all four Prom Night films, while makeup artist Nancy Howe worked on all three sequels.
Meanwhile, a new group of teenagers is preparing for prom at Hamilton High. Meagan and Mark and Jeff and Laura eventually decide to skip the dance and party at a church that has been converted into Mark’s parents’ summer house. Naturally, this brings them into direct conflict with Father Jonas.

How Prom Night IV Abandoned the Franchise
The development of Deliver Us from Evil began shortly after Prom Night III: The Last Kiss was released in 1990. British-Canadian producer Peter Simpson, who had worked on the previous three installments, wanted the series to change direction again. The first Prom Night had been a relatively straightforward teen stalk-and-slash movie starring Jamie Lee Curtis and Leslie Nielsen. Then Hello Mary Lou: Prom Night II introduced a supernatural element that made it feel more like a Carrie-inspired story. That gamble worked reasonably well, with the sequel breaking even at the box office and eventually developing a cult following. Prom Night III: The Last Kiss, however, went in an even more comedic direction.
For the fourth movie, Simpson hired writer Richard Beattie to give the franchise a more “intellectual” and “sardonic” tone. The result was anything but a conventional Prom Night movie.
Director Clay Boris was also an unusual choice for a horror franchise. His previous credits leaned more toward inexpensive action and television, including Quiet Cool, The Gunfighters, Night Heat, Rin Tin Tin: K9 Cops, and T and T. After Prom Night IV, he went on to direct episodes of Tropical Heat and Highlander: The Series.
Simpson later admitted that his original vision for Deliver Us from Evil hadn’t worked out as intended, and he blamed himself for choosing Boris.
The Making of Prom Night IV
Norstar Entertainment provided a Canadian $1.5 million budget, with principal photography beginning in February 1991. The movie was filmed in Toronto, including locations on Yonge Street, while Valley Halla Estate in Rogue Park was used for the main party house.
As you’d expect from a low-budget horror movie, the production recycled some of the franchise’s previous locations and footage. Interior shots of the 1957 prom were reused from Hello Mary Lou: Prom Night II, while establishing shots of Hamilton High came from The Last Kiss. Even the exterior used for Meagan’s house had previously appeared as Alex’s home in Part III.
For the most part, the shoot went smoothly. But one sequence nearly turned into a genuine disaster.
The Prom Night IV Stunt That Nearly Went Very Wrong
The movie’s climax finds Meagan battling Father Jonas before locking him inside a woodshed and setting it ablaze. Because Prom Night IV was made on such a small budget, Nicole de Boer later recalled that standard stunt safety procedures weren’t exactly a priority. According to de Boer, the director instructed her to dodge Jonas’ fireballs before striking the stuntman with a shovel.
“He [Jonas] throws a fireball at you; you jump to the left. He throws another, you jump to the right. Then he comes at you, and you hit him with the shovel. Hit him for real; he is padded.”
They began filming as planned. De Boer dodged the fireballs and struck the stuntman with the shovel. Then the stuntman, still on fire, suddenly began waving his arms and moving toward her. De Boer responded by hitting him with the shovel again. The director yelled “Cut!” and De Boer was then informed that the stuntman’s frantic waving wasn’t part of the scene. He was signaling that something had gone seriously wrong and that the fire needed to be extinguished immediately. Fortunately, the stuntman was fine.
Still, it’s one hell of an anecdote from a movie that otherwise has very little going for it.

Father Jonas Is One Weird Horror Villain
Father Jonas is easily one of the strangest villains in the Prom Night franchise. At various points, he falls from two stories and survives, apparently doesn’t age for 33 years, displays supernatural-looking abilities, and appears to share a psychic connection with Meagan. The movie never adequately explains any of it.
One of the more memorable kills comes when Jeff searches the attic for Laura after she has been murdered. Jonas puts Laura’s severed scalp over his own head to make Jeff believe he’s looking at his girlfriend before leaping out of the darkness, kissing him goodbye, and crushing his skull with his bare hands. It’s an effective enough horror image, but it raises even more questions. Is Jonas possessed? Does he have supernatural strength? Is he simply incredibly strong? Prom Night IV never bothers to give us an answer.
The movie also gives Jonas’ backstory an uncomfortable and poorly developed thematic connection between his childhood sexual abuse and his hatred of sexually active teenagers. Rather than creating a compelling portrait of a damaged villain, the film mostly leaves us wondering what the hell it’s trying to say.
There’s also an awkward sequence in which Laura attempts to seduce Meagan before revealing that the whole thing was apparently a joke to determine whether her friend is gay. Whatever the intended effect, the scene has aged terribly.
The Movie Barely Connects to Prom Night
Perhaps the strangest thing about Deliver Us from Evil is how little it has to do with the movies that came before it. There is no returning killer, no continuing storyline, and barely any connection to the previous three movies. The prom itself isn’t even really part of the story.
There is, however, one bizarre acknowledgment of the franchise’s history. While riding in a limo before the dance, Jeff raises a toast to Jamie Lee Curtis. Why? Your guess is as good as ours.
Curtis starred in the original Prom Night, so the reference is presumably intended as a wink to the franchise’s history. But considering how thoroughly Prom Night IV ignores everything else about the series, it only makes the decision more bewildering.
Mark Brings a Gun to a Knife Fight
If Father Jonas is the strangest part of Prom Night IV, Mark may be the character most deserving of a special award for terrible decision-making. After Mark and Meagan discover Jeff and Laura’s burning, crucified bodies, Meagan tries to call the police while Mark finds a gun in the house.
When Jonas suddenly appears and Meagan runs away, Mark has a gun. What does he do? He runs upstairs. Jonas has a knife. Mark has a gun. Mark never points it. He never fires it. He apparently forgets that he has it.
Eventually, Jonas stabs Mark in the foot, and Meagan finds the gun after Mark drops it. There are bullets on the ground nearby, creating yet another bizarre question: Was the gun unloaded? Did Mark never check it? Did he somehow fail to notice the ammunition? It’s a spectacularly dumb sequence in a movie that is already asking its audience to suspend an enormous amount of disbelief.

How Prom Night IV Ended the Franchise
The movie ends with Father Jonas apparently surviving and opening his eyes in the back of an ambulance. At the same time, Meagan opens her eyes. The implication is that the two now share some kind of psychic connection. It’s a cheap attempt to set up another sequel, but Prom Night IV performed so poorly that the franchise effectively ended there.
The movie received only a brief theatrical release in Canada in December 1991 and in Buffalo in February 1992. It subsequently went straight to video in the United States and internationally. The movie currently holds a 0% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
But here’s where the story gets even stranger.
There Was Supposed to Be a Prom Night V
Had Prom Night IV performed better, the franchise likely would have continued with a fifth installment, and the movie that was intended to become Prom Night V actually exists.
In 1994, Peter Simpson produced a low-budget slasher called The Club. The movie was originally titled The Club: Prom Night V. Unlike Deliver Us from Evil, at least The Club actually takes place at a prom.
The story follows students attending a prom inside a Gothic castle, where a deranged guidance counselor played by Kim Coates stalks and murders them after time briefly freezes.
The movie had virtually nothing to do with the previous Prom Night films, but that apparently wasn’t enough to stop it from being developed as the fifth installment.
The Club also stars J.H. Wyman, who played Mark in Prom Night IV. Here, he plays protagonist John Rotman, leader of the titular club. Wyman replaced Corey Haim, who was fired only two days into production.
Ultimately, producers dropped “Prom Night” from the title for its U.S. release. Some international territories, including Japan, retained the Prom Night name for video distribution. So depending on where you watched it, The Club was either an unrelated 1994 slasher or the fifth Prom Night movie. Welcome to the wonderfully bizarre history of this franchise.
Nicole de Boer Is the Best Thing About Prom Night IV
For all its problems, Prom Night IV does have one genuinely strong asset: Nicole de Boer. As Meagan, de Boer provides the movie with an effective Final Girl. She brings vulnerability and sincerity to a character who could easily have disappeared into the film’s otherwise ridiculous plot. Her performance becomes particularly sympathetic when Meagan talks about feeling overweight and inadequate, while her confrontation with Father Jonas gives de Boer an opportunity to physically carry the movie’s finale.
It’s no surprise that de Boer went on to have a solid career after Prom Night IV. She later appeared in Cube, played Ezri Dax on Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, and starred as Sarah Bracknell Bannerman in The Dead Zone. If there’s one reason to seek out Prom Night IV, it’s Nicole de Boer.
What Happened to Prom Night IV?
Prom Night IV: Deliver Us from Evil was an ambitious attempt to reinvent a franchise that had already reinvented itself twice. Unfortunately, the movie abandoned so much of what made Prom Night recognizable that there was almost nothing left connecting it to the series beyond the name, Hamilton High, and a few scattered references.
The decision to abandon the prom setting, discard the previous storylines, introduce a completely new killer, and steer the series toward a bizarre religious horror premise proved to be too much of a departure. The result was a fourth installment that effectively killed the franchise.
And yet, the story of Prom Night didn’t quite end there. The Club was developed as Prom Night V before the title was removed, leaving us with one of the strangest “almost sequels” in slasher history.
So that’s what happened to Prom Night IV. The franchise kept reinventing itself until there was barely anything left to recognize, and Deliver Us from Evil was finally one reinvention too many.
A couple of previous episodes of this show can be seen below. For more, check out the JoBlo Horror Originals YouTube channel—and don’t forget to subscribe!
The post How Prom Night IV became the sequel that killed the franchise appeared first on JoBlo.